Review: Enemies of the State (2020)

Enemies of the State is a documentary that will pique the interest of anyone fascinated by the murky world of espionage and government conspiracy. Directed by Sonia Kennebeck, this 2020 film dives into the complex and often eerie story of the DeHart family, who find themselves at the center of a web of allegations involving espionage, whistleblowing, and potential government overreach. As collectors, we're always on the hunt for unique narratives, and this film certainly offers a fresh perspective on modern paranoia and truth.

Plot Summary

The documentary introduces us to the DeHart family, whose son, Matt DeHart, a former Air National Guard member, is accused of being involved in espionage. This accusation leads the family into a perilous journey as they navigate accusations, flee to Canada seeking asylum, and battle against powerful institutions. The film is structured around interviews, archival footage, and dramatizations that create a narrative filled with twists and turns. Enemies of the State cleverly maintains a balance in revealing information, keeping viewers on their toes, and questioning what is truth and what might be a constructed narrative.

Performances

While Enemies of the State is a documentary, it relies heavily on the interviews and the people involved to drive its narrative. The key figures in the film, primarily the DeHart family, provide raw and emotional insights into their experiences. Matt DeHart's parents, Paul and Leann, deliver particularly strong accounts, as they oscillate between defending their son and dealing with the legal and emotional turmoil of their situation. The documentary also features experts and legal authorities who offer their perspectives, adding layers to the story. These interviews are well-conducted, and the subjects' sincerity and intensity contribute significantly to the film's impact.

Direction and Craft

Sonia Kennebeck's direction is focused and precise, guiding the audience through a labyrinth of information without losing sight of the human story at its core. The film's craft is notable, with its use of dramatizations that are both tasteful and effective in illustrating pivotal moments. Kennebeck's choice of visual style, combining stark interviews with shadowy reenactments, enhances the sense of mystery and tension. The editing is sharp, ensuring that the film remains engaging without becoming overwhelming, despite the dense subject matter. The use of archival footage is particularly effective, grounding the viewer in the reality of the situation while the narrative unfolds.

Collector's Verdict

As collectors, Enemies of the State is a documentary worth adding to your library, especially if you're a fan of true crime and stories about government intrigue. The Blu-ray format stands out as the best option for this film, as it captures the detailed visuals and enhances the overall viewing experience. While the film might not be the rarest find, it is uncommon enough to be a noteworthy addition to any collection focused on contemporary documentaries or political thrillers. The story's complexity and the presentation style make it a fascinating watch, sparking conversation and debate long after viewing.

In conclusion, Enemies of the State offers an intriguing exploration of paranoia, truth, and the gray areas in between. It might not answer every question it raises, but that's part of its allure—leaving us to ponder the nature of truth and the lengths people will go to protect it. For those who appreciate a documentary that challenges perceptions and engages with current issues, this is a film that delivers on multiple fronts. With a star rating of 3.5 out of 5, it earns its place in a discerning collector's catalog as an example of modern documentary storytelling done right.