Heaven's Gate (1980) Review

As a collector, you've probably heard about the infamous reputation of Michael Cimino's Heaven's Gate. Released in 1980, it was a box office disaster that nearly bankrupted United Artists and marked a significant turning point in Hollywood filmmaking. But like many films with tumultuous pasts, it's garnered a bit of a cult following over the years. Its journey from reviled to revered is a story in itself, making it a fascinating piece for any collector interested in film history.

Plot Summary

Set in the late 19th century, Heaven's Gate explores the conflict between European immigrants and wealthy cattle barons in Wyoming. The story follows Sheriff James Averill, played by Kris Kristofferson, as he navigates the tensions between the settlers and the established elite. The film paints a vivid picture of the era, focusing on themes of class struggle and the American Dream's often grim reality. While the plot is sprawling and complex, it’s best experienced without too much prior knowledge to appreciate its layers and nuances.

Performances

The film boasts an impressive ensemble cast. Kris Kristofferson delivers a stoic and measured performance as Averill, providing the film with a grounded center amid the chaos. Christopher Walken, as Nathan Champion, offers a more dynamic presence, bringing intensity and depth to his role. Isabelle Huppert plays Ella Watson, a bordello madam caught between the two men, with a subtlety and grace that adds emotional weight to the film's heavier moments.

Supporting roles include John Hurt, who brings a touch of elegance and melancholy as Billy Irvine, and Jeff Bridges, whose portrayal of John L. Bridges adds charm and levity to the narrative. The performances are one of the film’s strongest elements, with each actor fully committing to their roles despite the film's initial reception.

Direction and Craft

Michael Cimino's direction is nothing if not ambitious. The film’s production was notorious for its overblown budget and Cimino's demanding attention to detail. However, this meticulousness is evident in the final product. The cinematography by Vilmos Zsigmond is breathtaking, capturing the vast landscapes of the American West with an almost painterly quality. Every frame is rich with detail, contributing to the film's immersive atmosphere.

The film's production design and costumes also deserve mention for their authenticity and attention to period detail. Cimino's vision for Heaven's Gate as a grand epic is clear, even if it was criticized at the time for being overly indulgent. The film's pacing is deliberate, with scenes that unfold leisurely, allowing the viewer to soak in the atmosphere. This might be challenging for some, but it's a rewarding experience for those who appreciate the craftsmanship.

Collector's Verdict

For the collector, Heaven's Gate is an intriguing addition to any collection. Its history and the sheer scale of its production make it a significant piece of film lore. The best way to experience this visually stunning film is on Blu-ray, where the restored version brings out the full detail of Zsigmond's cinematography. The Criterion Collection's release, with its comprehensive extras and beautiful transfer, is particularly noteworthy.

While not exceedingly rare, the Blu-ray version is uncommon enough to be a valuable addition for those who appreciate the story behind the film as much as the film itself. Its restoration and the subsequent re-evaluation of its merits make Heaven's Gate a film worth revisiting and owning.

In conclusion, Heaven's Gate might not be for everyone, but for those interested in the history of film and the stories behind the movies, it provides a unique experience. Its ambitious scope, combined with its storied past, ensures that it remains a topic of discussion among cinephiles and collectors alike.