Review: Manhattan (1979)

Ah, the allure of New York City. Woody Allen's 'Manhattan' captures the romance, complexities, and raw beauty of the city like few films can. Released in 1979, this film is a love letter to the city, showcasing its skyline, streets, and iconic landmarks in stunning black and white. This choice alone sets it apart from many films of its time. For those who appreciate film as an art form, 'Manhattan' offers a unique experience that engages both the mind and the heart.

Plot Summary

The film follows the life of Isaac Davis, a twice-divorced, neurotic comedy writer played by Woody Allen himself. Isaac is caught in a web of relationships and personal struggles, reflective of the human condition and our perpetual search for love and meaning. His romantic entanglements include a 17-year-old high-school student named Tracy, played by Mariel Hemingway, and Mary Wilkie, the intellectual mistress of his best friend Yale, portrayed by Diane Keaton. As Isaac navigates these relationships, he also grapples with his career ambitions and his love for New York City.

Performances

Woody Allen, playing the lead character Isaac, brings his quintessential neurotic energy to the screen. His delivery is sharp and humorous, making Isaac's dilemmas both relatable and entertaining. Mariel Hemingway delivers a surprisingly mature performance as Tracy, exuding a sincerity and wisdom that defy her character's young age. Her portrayal earned her an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress, a reflection to her impact on the film.

Diane Keaton, as Mary, offers a engaging portrayal of a complex character who is both alluring and vulnerable. Her chemistry with Allen's Isaac is palpable, adding layers to their on-screen relationship. Supporting roles by Michael Murphy as Yale and Meryl Streep as Jill, Isaac's ex-wife, round out the cast, each contributing to the film's dynamic narrative with performances that feel genuine and nuanced.

Direction and Craft

Woody Allen's direction in 'Manhattan' is nothing short of meticulous. His decision to shoot the film in black and white was a bold choice that paid off, enhancing the film's artistic quality and classic appeal. The cinematography by Gordon Willis is exquisite, capturing the essence of New York City with an elegance that makes the city itself feel like a character in the story.

Allen's script, co-written with Marshall Brickman, is filled with witty dialogue and observational humor that reflect the director's unique voice. The film's score, featuring George Gershwin's music, complements the visuals perfectly, creating a mood that is both nostalgic and romantic.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, 'Manhattan' is a film that deserves a spot in any serious collection. The best format to own this film is undoubtedly Blu-ray. This format does justice to the film's stunning black and white cinematography, offering clarity and depth that older formats simply cannot match. While DVDs are more readily available, they don't capture the full grandeur of the visuals.

In terms of rarity, 'Manhattan' is somewhat uncommon, particularly in pristine condition on Blu-ray. The combination of Woody Allen's direction, the film's artistic merit, and its iconic status make it a valuable addition.

If you're a fan of Woody Allen or classic films, 'Manhattan' is a must-have. The Blu-ray version offers the best quality for collectors, ensuring that the film's visual and audio elements are experienced as intended.

Star Rating

With its engaging narrative, exceptional performances, and artistic direction, 'Manhattan' earns a solid 4.5 out of 5 stars. It's a film that not only entertains but also invites viewers to reflect on love, relationships, and the ever-changing landscape of New York City. As a collector, owning this piece of film history is a nod to an era of filmmaking that continues to inspire and resonate with audiences today.