Review: Shirley (2020)

In the 2020 film "Shirley", director Josephine Decker takes us on an intriguing journey into the enigmatic life of Shirley Jackson, one of America's most celebrated horror writers. Known for her unsettling stories and novels, Jackson's work has left a lasting impact on readers and writers alike. This film, however, is not a straightforward biopic. Instead, it blurs the lines between reality and fiction, much like Jackson's own writing, to explore the mind of a literary genius.

Plot Summary

"Shirley" centers around a young couple, Fred and Rose Nemser, who move in with Shirley Jackson and her husband, Stanley Hyman, a professor at Bennington College. Fred is a new faculty member, and the couple find themselves under the remarkable yet intimidating presence of Shirley. As Rose becomes more entangled with Shirley, she finds herself in a world that is as unsettling as it is magnetic. The film offers a look at the dynamics within the household, the creative process of Shirley Jackson, and the personal struggles she faces while crafting her stories.

Performances

Elizabeth Moss delivers a formidable performance as Shirley Jackson. She captures the complexity of Jackson's character, bringing to life her brilliance, paranoia, and vulnerability. Moss's portrayal is intense and layered, offering a deep dive into the mindset of a writer who thrived in the shadows of her own mind. Opposite Moss, Michael Stuhlbarg plays Stanley Hyman, providing a charismatic yet slightly unnerving presence. His performance as the supportive yet domineering husband adds an intriguing layer to the narrative.

Odessa Young, as Rose, offers a strong performance, capturing the transformation of her character from a naive newcomer to someone who becomes deeply entwined in Shirley's world. Logan Lerman, as Fred, complements Young's performance, though his character serves more as a backdrop to the unfolding drama between the main characters.

Direction and Craft

Josephine Decker's direction is both bold and subtle, creating an atmosphere that mirrors the eerie and claustrophobic feel of Jackson's stories. The film's visual style is a character in itself, with its muted color palette and intimate camerawork drawing viewers into the unsettling world of Shirley Jackson. The cinematography by Sturla Brandth Grøvlen enhances this mood, using close-ups and lingering shots to highlight the tension and emotional depth of the characters.

The screenplay by Sarah Gubbins, adapted from the novel by Susan Scarf Merrell, cleverly weaves fact and fiction, creating a narrative that feels both authentic and surreal. The score by Tamar-kali further accentuates the film's unsettling atmosphere, with its memorable melodies that echo the psychological complexity of the story.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, "Shirley" is a fascinating addition to any collection focused on biopics or psychological dramas. The Blu-ray edition stands out as the best format to own, offering a superior visual and audio experience that captures the film's moody and intricate style. While not particularly rare, this film is a valuable piece for those interested in the intersections of literature and film, as well as fans of Elizabeth Moss's exceptional acting.

In summary, "Shirley" (2020) is a film that both challenges and rewards its audience. With its strong performances, particularly from Elizabeth Moss, and its unique narrative approach, it offers a fresh perspective on the life of Shirley Jackson. The film's mixture of reality and fiction, under Decker's skilled direction, makes it a strong watch for anyone interested in the complexities of the creative mind.

Star Rating

I would rate "Shirley" a solid 4 out of 5 stars. It's a film that may not appeal to everyone, given its unconventional take on the biopic genre, but for those willing to engage with its unique storytelling, it provides a rich and thought-provoking experience.