Review: Shirley (2020)

When it comes to biographical films that take a creative twist, "Shirley" stands out as a fascinating exploration of its titular subject, the celebrated horror writer Shirley Jackson. Directed by Josephine Decker, the film is not your typical biopic. Instead, it combines elements of fact and fiction to create a psychological drama that feels as mysterious as one of Jackson's own novels. This film, released in 2020, is a engaging dive into the mind of a literary icon, offering a fresh perspective on the life and work of Shirley Jackson.

Plot Summary

"Shirley" centers around the period in which Shirley Jackson was writing her novel "Hangsaman". The story follows a young couple, Fred and Rose Nemser, who move into the home of Shirley and her husband, Stanley Hyman, a college professor. Rose becomes intrigued by Shirley's eccentric personality and her reclusive lifestyle. As the story unfolds, the lines between reality and fiction blur, reflecting the themes often found in Jackson's own work. The film weaves a narrative that is as much about the creative process as it is about the interpersonal dynamics between the characters.

Performances

The performances in "Shirley" are nothing short of impressive. Elisabeth Moss takes on the challenging role of Shirley Jackson with a nuanced performance that captures the complexity of Jackson's character. Moss brings a certain intensity to the role, balancing vulnerability with a sharp wit that makes Shirley both intimidating and fascinating. Michael Stuhlbarg, as Stanley Hyman, complements Moss with his portrayal of a charismatic yet manipulative figure. The chemistry between Moss and Stuhlbarg adds depth to the film, making their interactions a highlight.

Odessa Young, playing Rose Nemser, delivers a strong performance, capturing the transformation of her character as she becomes more deeply entwined in Shirley's world. Logan Lerman, as Fred Nemser, provides a steady counterpoint to the escalating tension in the household. The cast as a whole works seamlessly to bring this unique story to life, making each character's journey strong to watch.

Direction and Craft

Josephine Decker's direction in "Shirley" is both bold and inventive. She uses a variety of visual techniques to create a sense of unease and tension that mirrors the psychological themes of the film. The visual style is distinctive, with moody cinematography by Sturla Brandth Grøvlen that captures the oppressive atmosphere of the Jackson household. The use of light and shadow is particularly effective, emphasizing the film's exploration of the darker aspects of human nature.

The film's pacing is deliberate, allowing the story to unfold gradually and giving the audience time to absorb the intricacies of the plot. Tamar-kali's memorable score adds to the film's unsettling mood, enhancing the emotional impact of key scenes. The blending of fictional and real-life elements is handled skillfully, resulting in a narrative that feels both authentic and imaginative.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, "Shirley" offers a unique viewing experience that is best appreciated in high definition. The Blu-ray format is ideal for showcasing the film's rich visuals and atmospheric sound design. It's a common release, so finding a copy shouldn't be difficult, but the quality of the presentation makes it a valuable addition to any collection focused on psychological dramas or films about writers. The film's distinct approach to storytelling and its strong performances make it a worthwhile acquisition.

In terms of special features, the Blu-ray release includes insightful behind-the-scenes content that digs into into the making of the film. For those interested in the creative process behind "Shirley", these extras provide a deeper understanding of how Decker and her team brought this complex narrative to the screen.

Overall, "Shirley" is a film that will appeal to those who appreciate stories that challenge conventional biographical storytelling. Its blend of fact and fiction, combined with strong direction and strong performances, makes it a standout entry in the genre.

Star Rating

4.0 out of 5