Soldier Blue (1970)

When we talk about films that stir the pot, Soldier Blue is one that often comes to mind. Released in 1970, this film directed by Ralph Nelson takes a raw and unfiltered look at one of the more brutal chapters in American history. It's a movie that doesn't shy away from controversy, bringing a narrative that can be as polarizing as it is engaging. For collectors, it represents a piece of cinema that's both a product of its time and a comment on it.

Plot Summary

Soldier Blue follows the journey of two unlikely companions in the aftermath of a brutal attack on a cavalry unit. Cresta Lee, a spirited and outspoken woman with a past linked to Native Americans, and Honus Gant, a more traditional and duty-bound soldier, find themselves thrust together in survival mode. As they navigate the harsh landscapes of the American frontier, their differing perspectives on the conflict between Native Americans and American settlers come to the fore. This journey is not just a physical one but also an exploration of their views and beliefs, providing a narrative that questions the morality of the events unfolding around them.

Performances

Candice Bergen stars as Cresta Lee, delivering a performance that is both bold and nuanced. Bergen brings to life a character who is unafraid to speak her mind, challenging the status quo at every turn. Her portrayal is layered, offering a mix of vulnerability and strength that keeps you invested in her journey. Opposite her, Peter Strauss as Honus Gant provides a more restrained yet equally strong performance. His character's journey from black-and-white thinking to a more nuanced understanding is handled with care, making his transformation believable and impactful.

Donald Pleasence delivers a memorable supporting role as Isaac Q. Cumber, adding depth and intrigue to the story. His presence, though not central, adds a layer of tension and unpredictability that complements the lead performances. Overall, the cast does an admirable job of grounding the film’s more intense moments with genuine emotion and complexity.

Direction and Craft

Ralph Nelson’s direction of Soldier Blue is fearless in its approach to storytelling. He doesn't shy away from the brutal realities of the historical events depicted, opting instead to confront the audience with scenes that are as unsettling as they are thought-provoking. The film’s climax is particularly notable for its unflinching portrayal of violence, which has sparked much debate over the years about its necessity and impact.

The cinematography by Robert B. Hauser captures the vastness and beauty of the American frontier, providing a stark contrast to the violence that unfolds within its landscapes. The use of natural light and sweeping vistas creates an immersive experience that draws you into the world of the characters. The film's score, composed by Roy Budd, also deserves mention for its ability to enhance the emotional weight of the story without overwhelming it.

Collector's Verdict

For the discerning collector, Soldier Blue represents a unique point in film history. While it may not appeal to everyone due to its controversial content, it’s a film that warrants attention for its bold storytelling and historical commentary. The Blu-ray edition is the best format to own, offering improved picture and sound quality that do justice to the film’s visual and auditory elements.

Despite its uncommon status, finding a good copy can be a rewarding pursuit. The film’s rarity adds to its allure, making it a worthwhile addition to any collection that values films with historical significance and bold narratives.