Soldier Blue (1970) Review

Released at a time when the Western genre was evolving, 'Soldier Blue' is a film that sharply contrasts with the traditional Hollywood portrayals of the American West. This 1970 film, directed by Ralph Nelson, is as much a historical commentary as it is a Western, pushing boundaries with its unflinching depiction of violence and its critique of American history. As collectors, we often look for films that challenge the status quo, and 'Soldier Blue' certainly fits that bill.

Plot Summary

'Soldier Blue' follows the journey of Cresta Lee, played by Candice Bergen, and Honus Gant, portrayed by Peter Strauss. The two characters find themselves the sole survivors of a brutal attack on their cavalry unit by the Cheyenne. As they navigate the vast and unforgiving landscape towards safety, their journey becomes a backdrop for a larger narrative focused on the brutal realities of the conflicts between Native Americans and the U.S. Army. The film is notorious for its climactic sequence, which remains one of the most controversial depictions of violence in cinema.

Performances

Candice Bergen, known for her later roles in more mainstream fare, delivers a striking performance as Cresta Lee. She embodies a character that is both resilient and outspoken, offering a nuanced perspective on the events unfolding around her. Bergen's ability to convey both vulnerability and strength makes Cresta a strong character to follow. Peter Strauss, meanwhile, plays the role of Honus Gant with a sense of innocence and naivety that contrasts sharply with Bergen's world-weariness. His performance captures the internal conflict of a soldier caught between duty and moral questioning.

Supporting performances from actors like Donald Pleasence, who has a brief but memorable role, add depth to the narrative. Pleasence, with his distinct presence, contributes significantly to the film's tension and unpredictability, although the film primarily rests on the shoulders of its two leads.

Direction and Craft

Ralph Nelson's direction in 'Soldier Blue' is both bold and controversial. Known for pushing boundaries, Nelson does not shy away from depicting the harsh realities of the film's historical setting. His approach to storytelling is direct, often eschewing subtlety in favor of a more visceral impact. The film's graphic content, especially in its depiction of violence, serves as a stark reminder of the brutalities faced by Native Americans, forcing audiences to confront uncomfortable truths.

The cinematography by Robert B. Hauser effectively captures the expansive and often harsh landscapes of the American West. The visual style complements the film's thematic elements, providing an immersive experience that draws viewers into the era. The score by Roy Budd adds another layer to the film, balancing the intense visuals with a memorable musical backdrop that underscores the film's more dramatic moments.

Collector's Verdict

As collectors, 'Soldier Blue' presents an intriguing addition to any film library. Its controversial nature and historical context make it a significant piece of cinema history. While it may not be for everyone, due to its graphic content, it holds a place as a film that challenged and provoked dialogue about American history and the portrayal of Native Americans in film. For those interested in Westerns that break the mold, 'Soldier Blue' is a must-have.

When it comes to the best format, the Blu-ray edition offers the clearest picture and sound quality, which is crucial for appreciating the film's cinematography and score. However, finding a Blu-ray copy can be a bit of a treasure hunt, as it falls into the rare category, often requiring a bit of patience and luck to locate.

Overall, 'Soldier Blue' scores a 3.5 out of 5 stars. While it may not be perfect, its ambition and impact on the genre are undeniable. It's a piece of film history that deserves a spot in any serious collector's library, particularly for those interested in Westerns and controversial cinema.