Review: Song to Song (2017)

Let's talk about Terrence Malick's 'Song to Song', a 2017 film that divides audiences with its unconventional style. If you're familiar with Malick's work, you know to expect something that challenges traditional storytelling. 'Song to Song' is no different. It's set against the vibrant backdrop of the Austin, Texas music scene, and it weaves together the lives of several characters in a dance of love, betrayal, and creative ambition.

Plot Summary

In 'Song to Song', the plot isn't so much a linear progression as it is a series of interconnected moments. We have two struggling songwriters, Faye and BV, whose relationship becomes complicated by the presence of a manipulative producer, Cook. Faye is caught between her love for BV and her entanglement with Cook, which brings about a series of emotional and psychological challenges. The film explores how these characters interact with one another and their environments, creating a mosaic of experiences rather than a straightforward narrative. This is one of those films where the journey and the emotions it evokes are more significant than the destination.

Performances

The film boasts an impressive ensemble cast, including Rooney Mara, Ryan Gosling, Michael Fassbender, and Natalie Portman. Rooney Mara shines as Faye, bringing a quiet intensity to her role as a woman torn between her desires and ambitions. Ryan Gosling's BV is portrayed with a sense of earnestness and vulnerability that complements Mara's performance. Michael Fassbender brings a charismatic yet unsettling presence as Cook, the producer whose influence over the others is both magnetic and destructive. Natalie Portman, though her role is more limited, provides a poignant portrayal of a character who is drawn into Cook's world with tragic consequences.

It's worth noting that Malick's direction often involves a lot of improvisation, which can be both a boon and a challenge for actors. In 'Song to Song', the cast does an admirable job of adapting to this style, delivering performances that feel raw and authentic.

Direction and Craft

Terrence Malick is known for his poetic and visually stunning filmmaking, and 'Song to Song' continues in this vein. The film's visual language is rich, with cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki crafting beautiful, dreamlike sequences that capture the vibrancy of the Austin music scene. The camera work is fluid, often following characters in long, sweeping shots that feel like a dance in themselves. It's a visual feast for those who appreciate Malick's signature style.

However, Malick's approach to storytelling here is even more abstract than in his previous work. This can be polarizing; some viewers may find the lack of a structured plot frustrating, while others will appreciate the freedom to interpret the film's themes and emotions in their own way. The editing is non-linear, with scenes flowing into one another in a way that blurs the line between reality and imagination.

Music plays a vital role in 'Song to Song', both as a subject and a narrative device. The soundtrack, featuring a mix of rock, electronic, and classical music, underscores the emotional beats of the film and enhances its atmosphere. For those who love films where music is an integral character, this aspect of 'Song to Song' will definitely appeal.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors who appreciate the visual beauty and narrative style of Terrence Malick, 'Song to Song' is a worthwhile addition to your collection. It's a film that invites multiple viewings, each time offering something new to discover. The best format to own this film is Blu-ray, which does justice to Lubezki's stunning cinematography and the film's intricate sound design. While it's not the rarest title out there, its unique approach makes it uncommon and appealing for those who collect auteur cinema.

In wrapping up, 'Song to Song' is a film that may not be for everyone, but those who connect with it will find it to be a rewarding experience. It's a piece that speaks to the heart of creative ambitions and the complexities of human relationships, set to the rhythm of a strong soundtrack.