Starting Over (1979)

Ah, the late seventies—a time when romantic comedies began to embrace a more grounded take on relationships, moving away from the slapstick and screwball roots of earlier decades. Among these films, Starting Over stands out as a charming piece that combines humor with a touch of realism. Directed by Alan J. Pakula, renowned for his thrillers, this film is a delightful foray into the romantic comedy genre, offering a narrative that feels both classic and distinctly of its era.

Plot Summary

Starting Over follows the story of Phil Potter, played by Burt Reynolds, who finds himself in the throes of a personal crisis after his marriage to Jessica (Candice Bergen) ends. Forced to start anew, Phil moves to Boston, where he gets entangled in the complexities of dating and the awkwardness of new beginnings. His journey of self-discovery and romantic entanglements takes a turn when he meets Marilyn Holmberg, portrayed by Jill Clayburgh, a schoolteacher who is navigating her own emotional terrain. The film explores the balance between holding onto the past and embracing new possibilities, all while maintaining a humorous touch that keeps the audience engaged.

Performances

Burt Reynolds, often associated with more rugged or action-oriented roles, showcases a more vulnerable side in Starting Over. His portrayal of Phil is nuanced and relatable, capturing the essence of a man who is both charming and somewhat adrift. Reynolds' ability to balance humor with sincerity adds a layer of depth to his character, making Phil’s journey strong to watch.

Jill Clayburgh, who was in the midst of a career highlight during this period, brings warmth and complexity to Marilyn. Her chemistry with Reynolds is palpable, and she manages to convey a sense of independence and sensitivity that perfectly complements Phil's character. Candice Bergen, though in a smaller role, delivers a memorable performance as the ex-wife who is both frustrating and endearing. Her comedic timing is impeccable, adding a layer of humor that is both sharp and entertaining.

Direction and Craft

Alan J. Pakula, known primarily for his work in thrillers, surprises audiences with his adeptness at handling romantic comedy. His direction maintains a delicate balance between humor and the more serious undertones of the film, ensuring that the narrative remains engaging without becoming overly sentimental. The film’s pacing is steady, allowing the characters' development to unfold naturally.

The screenplay, penned by James L. Brooks, is sharp and witty, with dialogue that feels authentic and grounded. Brooks, who would go on to create numerous hits in both television and film, imbues the script with a blend of humor and heart that resonates throughout. The film’s score by Marvin Hamlisch complements the narrative beautifully, adding an emotional texture that enhances the viewing experience.

Visually, the film captures the essence of late 1970s America, with its urban settings and fashion choices that feel nostalgic today. The cinematography by Sven Nykvist, known for his collaboration with Ingmar Bergman, brings an understated elegance to the film, enhancing its overall charm.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, Starting Over is a delightful addition that showcases Burt Reynolds in a unique role, demonstrating his range beyond the typical action-oriented characters he is often synonymous with. The film’s blend of humor and heart makes it an engaging watch, and owning it on Blu-ray is particularly rewarding. The Blu-ray format captures the film’s visual nuances and ensures that the audio quality does justice to Marvin Hamlisch’s score. Given its uncommon status, finding a good quality Blu-ray can be a bit of a hunt, but it’s well worth the effort for those who appreciate romantic comedies that stray from the formulaic.

In terms of rarity, Starting Over is not the easiest title to stumble upon, especially in its best format. However, it’s not impossible to find, and the search can be part of the fun for dedicated collectors. Its unique place in the timeline of romantic comedies makes it a valuable piece for any serious collection.

Star Rating

4.0 out of 5 stars

Starting Over offers a humorous yet poignant look at the trials and triumphs of new beginnings, marked by strong performances and a deft directorial touch. It’s a film that is both reflective of its time and relatable to modern audiences, making it a worthwhile addition to any collection focused on the evolution of romantic comedies. If you're a fan of Burt Reynolds or just enjoy a well-crafted story of personal growth and romance, this is a film you’ll want to revisit. Grab it if you find it. You won't regret it.