Review: The Fog of War (2003)

Errol Morris's documentary, The Fog of War, provides an intriguing and revealing look into the life and thoughts of Robert S. McNamara, one of the most controversial figures in American political history. Released in 2003, this film does more than just recount historical events; it digs into into the ethical and philosophical questions that arise in the context of war. As a collector, it's one of those films that not only enriches your collection but also offers insightful content worth revisiting over time.

Plot Summary

The Fog of War isn't your typical documentary. It centers around an extended interview with Robert S. McNamara, the former U.S. Secretary of Defense, who played pivotal roles during the Vietnam War and the Cuban Missile Crisis. Through a series of “lessons” McNamara reflects on his experiences and decisions made during his tenure. The film doesn't just focus on his professional life but also touches on the human side of policy-making and the moral dilemmas faced by leaders. What's fascinating is how McNamara's reflections provide a window into the complexities of war and the burden of decision-making.

Performances

While traditional documentaries might not focus on performances, McNamara himself is the central figure, and his presence is nothing short of strong. His ability to articulate complex ideas with clarity and emotion makes him an engaging subject. It's not often that you find a documentary where the interviewee’s performance can be described as gripping, but McNamara manages to hold the viewer’s attention throughout. The candidness and introspection he brings to the film are key to its impact, making you ponder long after the credits roll.

Direction and Craft

Errol Morris is known for his unique style of documentary filmmaking, and The Fog of War is a reflection to his prowess. Morris effectively uses his Interrotron system, which allows subjects to look directly into the camera, creating a sense of direct communication with the audience. This technique is particularly effective here, as it feels like McNamara is speaking directly to you, making the experience more intimate and personal.

The film is masterfully edited, weaving together archival footage, audio recordings, and McNamara's interview seamlessly. Philip Glass’s memorable score underscores the narrative, adding a layer of emotional depth without overshadowing the subject matter. Morris's ability to craft a narrative that is both informative and thought-provoking speaks to his skill as a documentarian.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, The Fog of War is a valuable piece to own. The best format to consider is the DVD, which offers a good balance between video quality and availability. The DVD often includes additional interviews and commentary that can enhance your understanding of the film's themes. While not exceedingly rare, it is uncommon enough that having it in your collection will certainly be a conversation starter. Plus, the packaging often includes insightful extras that are a treat for any film enthusiast. In terms of rarity, it's more on the uncommon side, but definitely not impossible to find if you know where to look.

For those who appreciate documentaries that challenge conventional narratives and provoke thought, owning this film is a must. It’s not just about adding another title to your shelf, but about having a film that you can revisit and reflect upon, each time offering new insights.

In summary, The Fog of War is a documentary that stands out for its introspective approach to historical events and its ability to engage the audience on both an intellectual and emotional level. Whether you're a seasoned collector or new to documentary films, this is one that deserves a spot in your collection. It's a film that not only educates but also encourages viewers to question and think deeply about the complexities of leadership and war.