The Stars Look Down (1940) Review

Released in 1940, "The Stars Look Down" is a British drama film that holds a special place in the annals of cinema history. Directed by Carol Reed and based on the novel by A.J. Cronin, this film provides an insightful look into the struggles of a coal mining community in northern England. For collectors and enthusiasts of classic films, this movie offers a rich narrative set against a backdrop of social and economic issues that were prevalent at the time.

Plot Summary

Without giving too much away, "The Stars Look Down" follows the journey of a young man named Davey Fenwick, played by Michael Redgrave, who is determined to make a difference in his small mining town. The film paints a picture of the harsh realities faced by miners and their families, highlighting themes of ambition, corruption, and social justice. As Davey navigates his way through the complexities of his environment, he confronts both personal and communal challenges, making for a story that is as engaging as it is thought-provoking.

Performances

The performances in this film are nothing short of impressive. Michael Redgrave's portrayal of Davey Fenwick is both earnest and strong, capturing the essence of a man caught between his ambitions and the weight of his roots. He brings a depth to the character that is both relatable and inspiring. Margaret Lockwood, playing Jenny Sunley, delivers a performance that complements Redgrave's, offering a nuanced depiction of a woman torn between personal desire and societal expectations. The supporting cast, including Emlyn Williams as Joe Gowlan and Nancy Price as Martha Fenwick, round out the ensemble with performances that are equally strong, each adding layers to the film's narrative.

Direction and Craft

Carol Reed's direction is a standout element of "The Stars Look Down." Known for his ability to bring complex narratives to life, Reed excels in creating an atmosphere that is both authentic and immersive. His attention to detail is evident in the way he captures the gritty reality of the mining town, making the setting almost a character in its own right. The film's cinematography, handled by Flavio Mogherini, contributes to this, with stark black-and-white visuals that enhance the film's somber tone. The score, composed by Muir Mathieson, complements the narrative perfectly, emphasizing the emotional weight of the story without overpowering it.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, "The Stars Look Down" is a significant addition to any collection of classic British films. The VHS format, in particular, offers a unique viewing experience that captures the film's original essence. Although the film has seen some releases on DVD, the VHS version holds a certain charm, with its grainy texture and vintage appeal. It's not the easiest find, making it an uncommon but valuable piece for those who appreciate the history and evolution of film format technologies. Securing a copy might take some effort, but it's well worth it for the dedicated collector.

In conclusion, "The Stars Look Down" is a film that resonates on multiple levels, both as a narrative and as a piece of historical cinema. Its exploration of themes like ambition, social justice, and the human condition remains relevant, making it a film that is not only worth watching but also worth owning.

Star Rating: 4.0/5