The Third Man (1949) Review

Set against the shadowy, war-torn backdrop of Vienna, The Third Man remains a quintessential piece of film noir that has captivated audiences for decades. Directed by Carol Reed and featuring a screenplay by the legendary Graham Greene, this movie is more than just a classic thriller. It’s a journey through a time when the world was recovering from immense upheaval and uncertainty. As a collector, owning a piece of this visual history is like having a window into a world that is both distant and hauntingly familiar.

Plot Summary

Without giving away any spoilers, The Third Man follows American writer Holly Martins, played by Joseph Cotten, as he arrives in post-war Vienna. He’s there at the invitation of his old friend Harry Lime, only to find that Lime has recently died under suspicious circumstances. As Martins begins to dig deeper into the circumstances of Lime’s death, he uncovers a shadowy underworld of deception and intrigue. The more he learns, the more questions arise, especially about who Harry Lime really was and the implications of his actions in a city divided by occupation.

Performances

The performances in The Third Man are nothing short of stellar. Joseph Cotten delivers a strong performance as Holly Martins, capturing the character’s naivety and determination with great skill. Alida Valli, as Anna Schmidt, brings a blend of strength and vulnerability, effectively portraying a woman caught in the complexities of love and loyalty.

However, it’s Orson Welles who steals the show, despite his relatively limited screen time. His portrayal of Harry Lime is iconic, and he imbues the character with a charisma that is both charming and unsettling. Welles’ presence looms large over the film, creating an enigmatic figure that remains central to the plot even when he’s not on screen. Trevor Howard as Major Calloway also deserves praise for his nuanced performance, which adds depth to the story’s moral complexity.

Direction and Craft

Carol Reed’s direction is a standout aspect of The Third Man. His use of lighting and shadow is exemplary, defining the film’s mood and tension. The decision to shoot on location in Vienna adds an authentic layer to the film, with the city itself becoming a character in the story. The decaying grandeur of post-war Vienna, captured in striking black and white, enhances the film’s noir aesthetic and immerses the audience in its world.

A special mention must be made of the film’s score, composed by Anton Karas. The zither music is one of the most memorable aspects of the film, providing a unique auditory experience that complements the visual style. It’s rare for a score to become as iconic as the film itself, but Karas achieved this with a sound that is instantly recognizable and evocative.

The screenplay by Graham Greene is tightly woven, filled with suspense and wit. Greene’s writing captures the moral ambiguity and existential themes that were prevalent in post-war literature and cinema. The dialogue is sharp, with moments of humor that provide a brief respite from the film’s darker themes.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, The Third Man is an essential addition to any serious film library. The best format to own this classic is the Blu-ray release, which offers a beautifully restored version of the film. The clarity of the picture and the crispness of the sound make this format the ideal way to experience the film’s atmospheric visuals and iconic score.

In terms of rarity, The Third Man is considered rare, particularly in pristine condition. Special edition releases or those with unique packaging can be especially hard to find, but they’re worth seeking out for the dedicated collector. The film’s historical significance and its impact on the noir genre make it a valuable piece for any collection.

In conclusion, The Third Man offers a perfect blend of suspense, drama, and visual artistry. It’s a film that not only entertains but also provokes thought and discussion, making it a classic piece of cinema history. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or new to the world of classic films, The Third Man is a title that deserves a place on your shelf.

Star Rating

I’d give The Third Man a solid 4.5 out of 5 stars. It’s a film that stands out for its direction, performances, and its unique place in the annals of film history. As a collector, owning this film is like having a piece of the golden era of cinema, and its appeal endures, making it a must-have for any enthusiast.