Thieves Like Us (1974) Review

You know those films that seem to fly under the radar but still manage to leave a lasting impression? Thieves Like Us is one of those gems. Directed by Robert Altman, this 1974 crime drama is an adaptation of the novel by Edward Anderson. It shares its source material with Nicholas Ray's They Live by Night from 1948. Altman's take is a quieter, more introspective journey into the lives of Depression-era bank robbers. With a focus on character development and setting, it stands out for its subtlety and attention to detail.

Plot Summary

Set in the American South during the Great Depression, Thieves Like Us follows three bank robbers—Bowie, Chicamaw, and T-Dub—after they escape from a Mississippi prison. As they resume their criminal activities, Bowie, played by Keith Carradine, finds himself torn between the life of crime and a budding romance with Keechie, a young woman portrayed by Shelley Duvall. The film explores their struggle with fate, love, and the inevitable consequences of their choices. It's less about glorifying crime and more about examining the personal and moral dilemmas faced by its characters.

Performances

Keith Carradine delivers a nuanced performance as Bowie. His portrayal is both gentle and conflicted, perfectly capturing a young man trapped in a life he wishes to escape. Shelley Duvall, as Keechie, complements Carradine with her unique blend of vulnerability and strength. Their chemistry is palpable, giving the film an emotional core that resonates long after the credits roll.

Supporting performances are equally impressive. John Schuck as Chicamaw and Bert Remsen as T-Dub add layers of complexity to their characters, providing a sense of camaraderie and tension within the group. Each actor brings a raw authenticity to their roles, making the viewer feel the weight of their desperate circumstances.

Direction and Craft

Robert Altman's direction is methodical and restrained, focusing on the human aspects of the story rather than sensationalizing the criminal elements. He uses long takes and naturalistic dialogue to create an immersive experience, drawing the audience into the era and the characters' lives. The film's pacing is deliberate, allowing viewers to absorb the atmosphere and emotions simmering beneath the surface.

Visually, Thieves Like Us is a treat. Cinematographer Jean Boffety captures the dusty landscapes and worn-out towns of the Depression-era South with a keen eye for detail. The muted color palette contributes to the film's authentic feel, while the use of natural lighting enhances its realism.

Altman's decision to use period-appropriate radio broadcasts as the film's soundtrack is a stroke of genius. These broadcasts provide context and commentary, subtly reinforcing the film's themes without resorting to a traditional score.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, Thieves Like Us is a gem that deserves a spot on your shelf, especially if you're a fan of 70s crime dramas or Robert Altman's work. The best format to own this film is the Blu-ray release, which offers superior picture quality and sound over older formats like VHS or DVD. It's not the most common title to find, especially in pristine condition, but it's certainly worth the hunt.

The Blu-ray version provides a crisp, clear presentation of Altman's vision, allowing you to fully appreciate the film's visual nuances. It often includes insightful special features, such as commentary tracks or documentaries, which add value for any collector interested in the filmmaking process.

In terms of rarity, Thieves Like Us is uncommon but not impossible to find. It might require a bit of searching through specialty stores or online platforms dedicated to classic films. However, the effort is rewarding, as you'll be adding a thoughtful piece of cinema history to your collection.

Overall, Thieves Like Us is a must-see for anyone who appreciates a well-crafted story with strong performances and authentic direction. Altman's film provides a reflective look at crime and consequence, making it an engaging watch for both casual viewers and serious collectors alike.