Review: Thieves Like Us (1974)

Thieves Like Us, released in 1974, is a film that perfectly encapsulates the era it portrays while offering a narrative that balances crime and romance. Directed by the highly regarded Robert Altman, the movie takes us on a journey through 1930s America, filled with bank heists, police chases, and the tender moments of a budding romance. For collectors who appreciate the intricate storytelling of Altman, this film is a notable piece worth exploring.

Plot Summary

Set during the Great Depression, Thieves Like Us follows a trio of bank robbers: Bowie, Chicamaw, and T-Dub. Having escaped from a Mississippi prison, the group quickly returns to their criminal ways, robbing banks across the state. Despite their outlaw lifestyle, the film takes a poignant turn when Bowie, the youngest of the group, falls in love with Keechie, a young woman who offers him a glimpse of a life beyond crime. As their relationship develops, Bowie is torn between his love for Keechie and his commitment to his partners in crime. The story unfolds with a steady pace, keeping viewers engaged without giving away too much too soon.

Performances

The performances in Thieves Like Us are a significant highlight, with Keith Carradine and Shelley Duvall leading the cast. Carradine plays Bowie with a quiet intensity that perfectly captures the character's internal struggle between his criminal inclinations and his desire for a different life. Shelley Duvall, known for her unique presence, brings a natural charm to Keechie, making her a strong and relatable character. Their chemistry is palpable, adding a layer of authenticity to their on-screen romance.

The supporting cast, including John Schuck as Chicamaw and Bert Remsen as T-Dub, deliver solid performances that round out the trio of bandits. Each character is portrayed with a depth that makes them more than just sidekicks in Bowie's story. This ensemble cast works seamlessly together, creating a believable world that draws viewers in with its nuanced portrayals of desperation and longing.

Direction and Craft

Robert Altman's direction in Thieves Like Us is a reflection to his ability to blend style with substance. The film is visually striking, capturing the essence of the 1930s with meticulous attention to detail. From the period-accurate costumes to the evocative settings, Altman creates a world that feels both authentic and immersive. His use of naturalistic dialogue and overlapping conversations adds to the realism, a trademark of Altman's work that fans will recognize and appreciate.

The cinematography by Jean Boffety complements Altman's vision, using soft lighting and expansive landscapes to evoke the bleak yet beautiful atmosphere of the Depression-era South. The film's pacing is deliberate, allowing the story to unfold naturally without feeling rushed. Altman’s careful crafting of each scene ensures that every moment, whether it involves tension-filled heists or quiet interactions between Bowie and Keechie, is impactful.

The soundtrack, featuring period-appropriate music, further enhances the film's authenticity. It subtly underlines the emotional beats of the story, without overwhelming the narrative. Altman’s choice to avoid a traditional score, instead opting for tunes that characters might realistically hear, grounds the film in its time and place.

Collector's Verdict

For film collectors, Thieves Like Us represents a piece of cinema that combines Robert Altman's distinctive style with a strong narrative. The best format to own would be the Blu-ray version, which offers improved picture and sound quality that bring out the film's rich details. While it's not the rarest title in Altman's filmography, it's uncommon enough to be a prized addition to a collection focused on crime dramas or Altman's oeuvre. The film's blend of romance and crime against a historical backdrop makes it a unique offering that stands apart from more conventional entries in the genre.

In conclusion, Thieves Like Us is a strong find for collectors with a taste for crime dramas and the unique style of Robert Altman. Its combination of strong performances, authentic period detail, and Altman's signature direction make it a film worth seeking out and adding to your collection.