Water (2005) Review

In 2005, Deepa Mehta released 'Water', the third installment of her Elements Trilogy. Set against the backdrop of 1938 India, the film explores the lives of widows relegated to a life of austerity and marginalization. This film doesn't just tell a story but opens a window into a world that many of us may not be familiar with. As a collector, films like 'Water' offer a narrative filled with cultural depth and historical significance.

Plot Summary

'Water' is set in a time when India was on the brink of independence, yet many of its social customs remained unchanged. The story follows an eight-year-old girl named Chuyia, who, after being widowed, is sent to a home for Hindu widows to live out the rest of her life in renunciation. The narrative unfolds as Chuyia becomes entwined with the lives of other widows, particularly Kalyani, a young widow who falls in love with Narayan, a man who dreams of a modern India free from such oppressive traditions. Through the eyes of Chuyia and Kalyani, the film portrays a poignant struggle for personal freedom against the backdrop of societal rigidity.

Performances

The performances in 'Water' are nothing short of impressive. Sarala Kariyawasam, who plays Chuyia, delivers a performance that is both innocent and profound. It's remarkable how she captures the essence of a child thrust into a world she cannot comprehend. Lisa Ray as Kalyani brings a delicate strength to her role. Her portrayal of a woman caught between tradition and desire is both touching and strong. John Abraham, in the role of Narayan, provides a nuanced performance that embodies idealism and hope for change. Seema Biswas, playing the role of Shakuntala, stands out with her portrayal of a widow who is torn between her faith and her sense of justice. Each actor brings a layer of authenticity to the film, making the characters deeply relatable.

Direction and Craft

Deepa Mehta's direction is both sensitive and powerful. She doesn't shy away from presenting the stark realities of the widows' lives, yet she does so with a grace that allows the viewer to engage deeply with the narrative. The cinematography by Giles Nuttgens is stunning, capturing the beauty of the Indian landscape while juxtaposing it with the harshness of the widows' existence. The use of natural light and vibrant colors enhances the emotional depth of the film.

The film's score, composed by A.R. Rahman, complements the visuals beautifully. The music captures the essence of the period and the emotional undertones of the story. Mehta's ability to weave together these elements results in a film that is not only visually appealing but also emotionally resonant.

Collector's Verdict

For collectors, 'Water' is a film that holds significant value, both in terms of its content and its production history. Despite facing numerous challenges during its making, including political opposition, Mehta's perseverance paid off, resulting in a film that speaks volumes about resilience and the human spirit. The Blu-ray edition is the best format to own, offering superior picture quality that does justice to the film's stunning visuals. However, it's worth noting that this edition is somewhat rare, making it a prized possession for any film enthusiast interested in social narratives.

In conclusion, 'Water' is a film that is as relevant today as it was upon its release. It challenges viewers to reflect on societal norms and personal liberation. The performances, direction, and overall craftsmanship make it a significant addition to any collection.

With its thoughtful exploration of societal issues and its artistic execution, 'Water' earns a 4.5 out of 5 stars in my book. It's a must-have for those who appreciate films that are both thought-provoking and beautifully crafted.