Sarah Michelle Gellar solidified her status as a genre icon through a string of memorable roles that remain highly sought-after by physical media collectors. While she soared to international fame as Buffy Summers, it was her cinematic ventures in the late 90s and early 2000s that truly cemented her place in horror and teen drama history. Collectors actively seek out pristine editions of films like 1997's *I Know What You Did Last Summer*, a slasher cornerstone, and *Scream 2* from the same year, showcasing her as a prominent figure in the post-modern horror revival. Beyond the screams, Gellar showcased remarkable versatility. The cult classic *Cruel Intentions* (1999) is a must-have for its sharp dialogue and Gellar's captivating performance. Her work also extends to more offbeat selections like *Suburban Girl* (2007), often valued by collectors for its unique tone and Gellar's turn in an indie dramedy. These films, especially on their original VHS, DVD, or early Blu-ray pressings, are tangible pieces of a pivotal era in film and Gellar’s undeniable impact on popular culture.