Are Crooks Dishonest?

About This Movie

Are Crooks Dishonest? is a lighthearted 1918 comedy that brings together the antics of two con artists, Harold and Snub, as they try to pull one over on a fraudulent psychic, Miss Goulash, and her equally dubious father. The film has a sort of whimsical charm, with a playful tone that reflects the era's fascination with spiritualism and trickery. The practical effects are amusingly rudimentary yet effective in crafting the illusion of the psychic phenomena they mock. The pacing feels relaxed, allowing for comedic moments to breathe. Performances are spirited, especially from the leads, who exude a camaraderie that adds to the film's overall liveliness. It’s a delightful glimpse into the silent comedy genre, showcasing the cleverness of its time.

This film is quite rare in collector circles. Its silent format often limits availability, with only a handful of prints known to exist. The combination of comedy and a critique of early 20th-century spiritualism makes it an interesting study for enthusiasts of the genre. Recent interest has grown, particularly among those keen on the nuances of silent era storytelling.