Should a Girl Marry?

About This Movie

Should a Girl Marry? is quite an intriguing piece from 1939, blending crime and romance in a rather unconventional way. The plot revolves around a young woman, caught in a tight spot when her past comes back to haunt her—she was born in prison, which sets off a tense blackmail scenario. The performances are solid, bringing a genuine emotional weight that underscores the themes of societal judgment and personal redemption. The atmosphere has this noir-ish tension, though it lacks the flashy production values of its contemporaries. The pacing feels a bit uneven at times, but it adds to the overall charm. It’s definitely one of those lesser-known gems that offers a unique look at the darker side of relationships during that era.

This film has a bit of a shadowy presence in the collector community, with limited print runs and few home media releases over the years. It seems to have gained traction among those who appreciate the quirky blend of crime and romance typical of the late 30s era. Original theatrical posters and lobby cards are surprisingly scarce, which adds to its allure for collectors who enjoy the hunt for unique titles.