Some Liar

About This Movie

Some Liar is a fascinating blend of comedy and Western, showcasing a traveling salesman with a flair for exaggeration. Set in the dusty town of Yellow Jacket, Arizona, Robert Winchester McTabb, played with a certain charm, peddles his unusual wares: coffins and cradles. The atmosphere is a quirky mix of humor and the dry, rugged backdrop typical of early Westerns. The pacing has a leisurely feel, allowing the absurdity of McTabb's tall tales to unfold, while Celie Sterling's challenge brings a sharp twist to the narrative. It’s the oddball character interactions and the whimsical take on death and commerce that makes this film distinctive, not to mention the practical effects of the time that lend a certain charm.

Some Liar, being from 1919, is a bit of a rarity in the collector's circuit. Finding an original print or any format can be quite the hunt due to its age and the obscurity surrounding its production, especially with a director whose name remains uncredited. This film garners interest for its unique blend of humor and Western tropes, making it a curious piece for collectors looking to delve into the lesser-known comedies of the silent film era.