What an Eye

About This Movie

What an Eye (1924) is quite the peculiar blend of comedy and horror that feels like a strange time capsule from the Roaring Twenties. The story revolves around Buddy, an office-boy on a quest for manhood, which leads him into a bizarre investigation involving a mysterious eye causing quite the ruckus among the ladies. The pacing is a bit erratic, but that’s part of its charm, keeping you engaged in its offbeat humor and unexpected thrills. The practical effects, though modest, add a certain whimsicality to the eerie atmosphere. Performances are spirited, capturing that bygone era’s unique energy, making it a distinctive piece of cinema that reflects its time well.

What an Eye has seen limited release on physical media, making original prints rather hard to come by, which naturally attracts the attention of collectors. Its rarity is compounded by obscurity, as it lacks the mainstream recognition of many films from its era. For those interested in early horror-comedies, this film is a noteworthy curiosity, with its unusual premise and charm that appeals to niche collectors seeking something off the beaten path.