Which of the Nine?

About This Movie

Which of the Nine? is a fascinating short from 1957, directed by Istvan Szőts, though the director's identity often seems to be overshadowed by the film itself. The performances by József Bihari and Andor Ajtay lend a unique warmth that complements its Christmas theme, drawing viewers into a sort of nostalgic reverie. The pacing is delicate, with a focus on atmosphere over narrative speed, which allows the themes of generosity and reflection to breathe. The film’s roots in Mór Jókai’s novel give it a rich literary backdrop, and it’s intriguing how it translates those elements into a visual medium—practical effects are subtle but effective, aligning nicely with the overall tone. Definitely one for serious collectors who appreciate the nuance of mid-century cinema.

This film has seen limited releases over the years, which makes finding a clean print somewhat challenging. Depending on your region, it may only exist in niche festival circuits or private collections, adding to its allure. Collectors tend to be particularly interested in its Venice Film Festival debut, which lends it a certain prestige, though it remains overshadowed by more prominent works from that era. The short's unique approach and literary adaptation make it a compelling piece for those delving into lesser-known Hungarian cinema.